This is related to the other "Integrated Reserve" thread but I wanted to get your views on this in a poll. As the integration is treated like a course for the first year (to bring RDF soldiers up to standard), could we not recruit from Civi street and make it a 2, or 3 year course?
Recruiting Integrated RDF soldiers from civi-street would have several advantages as far as I can see:
- Non-integrated officers and Cadre wouldn't be able to hinder recruitment
- Bad habits present in the RDF wouldn't be allowed to develop
- Potential for larger numbers in highly populated areas
- Imbalance in the ranks could be easily addressed
Disadvantages:
- Large initial drop-out rate
- Requirment for increased training resources
- More time would have to be spent on recruitment for (what could be) minimul return
- Recruitment could conflict with local RDF units
Recruiting Integrated RDF soldiers from civi-street would have several advantages as far as I can see:
- Non-integrated officers and Cadre wouldn't be able to hinder recruitment
- Bad habits present in the RDF wouldn't be allowed to develop
- Potential for larger numbers in highly populated areas
- Imbalance in the ranks could be easily addressed
Disadvantages:
- Large initial drop-out rate
- Requirment for increased training resources
- More time would have to be spent on recruitment for (what could be) minimul return
- Recruitment could conflict with local RDF units
Comment