Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

comissioning from the ranks

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
    GoneToTheCanner
    C/S

  • GoneToTheCanner
    replied
    Hi all
    Bandit, nepotism exists at all levels in the PDF.There is no shortage of brothers of brothers, sons of, cousins of,etc. How often do you see photos in the Cosantoir of extended families in uniform. There's even been twins getting commissioned! The Army is just a microcosm of the population it exists in and the sad fact is that family ties are held in higher regard than actual merit.
    regards
    GttC

    Leave a comment:

  • Snacker
    Battalion Sargeant Major

  • Snacker
    replied
    In the royal marines officers and non enlisted men all do the same basic training.

    Leave a comment:

  • BANDIT
    Banned User

  • BANDIT
    replied
    I think any means that would open up opportunities for non-coms to be commissioned would be an improvement. When I was in two people from my batt were sent on potential officwers courses , one deserved it and the other well by some coincidence he was married to a Comdts daughter and was as not a particularly good soldier. Just look at teh names of those pasing out.. its an old boys club.
    There apperas to be a considerable degree of nepotism involved. What percentage of cadets( less the zambians) are sons , daughters etc of serving or former officers. How many view it as simply a way to get a degree paid for etc ,
    In recent yeARS I have worked with a number of people who have come through the ranks, One full Col,s BA three former majors , and all but one were Irish. I have also worked with a former Comdt. (I was his boss) who could not get over the fact that I was a former NCO, who had left worked , gone back to college am well qualified .. He was still stuck in the days of the Raj, Officers and their ladies, Men and their women etc. His contract was not renewed.
    So to keep it short make it compulsory for all potential cadets to spend a year in the ramks before going anywhere and bring in the French or someone else to select cadets.

    MOD: Names removed to protect the innocent.

    Leave a comment:

  • happenin
    Lieutenant

  • happenin
    replied
    Thats what i was thinking alright barry. Thanks for clearing that up.

    Leave a comment:

  • ODIN
    Lt General

  • ODIN
    replied
    Will there be a big uptake of this within the ranks??And will there be a glass celling

    Leave a comment:


  • WES
    replied
    Originally posted by Barry
    Now a potential officers course is being run, which operates in a similar manner to the RDF officers course.
    Potential Officers Courses have been run for years. You ahd to be an NCO and under age 32 to qualify.

    Leave a comment:

  • ODIN
    Lt General

  • ODIN
    replied
    Obviously I did Barry...no need to be a smart arse all your life now is there??

    Leave a comment:

  • Barry
    Lt General

  • Barry
    replied
    Originally posted by happenin
    Ok For those like me who are used to this in the rdf. Is there a different system for the pdf. How does the whole process work. Is there extra training involved and if so is it equivelant to a cadetship?
    For several years now the only way for other ranks to become ossifers was to apply for the cadetship the same way as a civvy would, with the obvious advantage of having a percentage bonus and some knowledge of what the army is like. Now a potential officers course is being run, which operates in a similar manner to the RDF officers course.
    Originally posted by Odin_ie
    Unless you become a Major!!!
    You mean a Sgt Major?

    Leave a comment:

  • ODIN
    Lt General

  • ODIN
    replied
    Originally posted by hedgehog
    They can blow it out their tubes

    There is no way I am lowering my standards of professionalism

    just to wear a peak cap and sam browne belt
    Unless you become a Major!!!

    Leave a comment:


  • hedgehog
    replied
    Competition for soldiers to become officers
    They can blow it out their tubes

    There is no way I am lowering my standards of professionalism

    just to wear a peak cap and sam browne belt

    Leave a comment:

  • ODIN
    Lt General

  • ODIN
    replied
    Have met a few officers who have come up like this but had a glass celling of Cmdt.

    Leave a comment:

  • yellowjacket
    Potential Liability

  • yellowjacket
    replied
    It was "totally unacceptable" that for several years no enlisted person had an opportunity to apply for officer rank.
    Haven't a fair few former enlisted people been selected for cadetships in recent years?

    Leave a comment:

  • happenin
    Lieutenant

  • happenin
    started a topic comissioning from the ranks

    comissioning from the ranks

    Posts: 44 Competition for soldiers to become officers

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Competition for soldiers to become officers
    Frank McNally


    Non-commissioned soldiers will have a more chances of attaining officer rank following a decision by Minister for Defence Willie O'Dea to establish regular promotion competitions.

    Mr O'Dea announced that a Commissioning From the Ranks competition would be held this year - the first in almost five years - and its outcome would decide his approach to future competitions.

    A spokeswoman for the Minister said it was a question of "how often" rather than whether further competitions would be held. Mr O'Dea hoped the move would dispel perceptions of a "glass ceiling" to promotion in the Defence Forces.


    The soldiers' representative body Pdforra welcomed the "long-awaited decision" to regularise commissioning from the ranks, which until now has been done on an ad-hoc basis.

    Deputy general secretary Simon Devereux said there was no valid reason why anyone who joined the Defence Forces as a recruit could not go "to the very top of the organisation, provided they have what it takes to do so". It was "totally unacceptable" that for several years no enlisted person had an opportunity to apply for officer rank.

    © The Irish Times 06.05.2006





    Ok For those like me who are used to this in the rdf. Is there a different system for the pdf. How does the whole process work. Is there extra training involved and if so is it equivelant to a cadetship?
Working...
X