Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Methods of Command

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
    Thorpe
    Sergeant Major

  • Thorpe
    replied
    In our Bn our PDF officers do help out alot compaired to others I have seen. The new breed of RDF officer is a whole lot better that his / her older conterpart.

    Leave a comment:

  • Loque
    Loose Cannon

  • Loque
    replied
    A combination of both is the best, but only if you have a good officer, a bad one will just end up pissing off the NCO's and pull rank to cover up his/her mistakes.

    Leave a comment:

  • Come-quickly
    Commandant

  • Come-quickly
    replied
    I'm not I'm suggesting that their training technique is best,, for warfighting troops anyway, I doubt they'd make good OOTW personnel

    Leave a comment:

  • Guest
    Guest

  • medic
    Guest replied
    There is no way you can compare the IDF to us.

    Leave a comment:

  • Come-quickly
    Commandant

  • Come-quickly
    replied
    One word "Israel"

    Leave a comment:

  • Guest
    Guest

  • medic
    Guest replied
    Why?

    Leave a comment:

  • Guest
    Guest

  • DriverGirl
    Guest replied
    As with everything, a moderate approach is best. I think it's better if the NCO's do all the classroom and theory work, and the officers only come in on practical experience such as shooting and being on the ground.

    Leave a comment:

  • Guest
    Guest

  • medic
    Guest replied
    I take it you mean RDF officers as being helpful. Most PDF offrs would work to keep warm

    Leave a comment:

  • Thorpe
    Sergeant Major

  • Thorpe
    replied
    I feel a combination of both is best as sometimes officers can be a hinderence to training rather than help and sometimes the opposite is true. Most officers especially are very hands on and are will to help out and are not a hinderence but are really a good help. Some older officers you want to kepp as far a wa as possible.

    Leave a comment:

  • Guest
    Guest

  • medic
    Guest replied
    I know there are exceptions but I don't honestly believe that many people have faith in Irish offr's leadership skills anyway

    Leave a comment:

  • T.I.M.
    Beard On

  • T.I.M.
    replied
    Has to be the Hands on approach, if the commanding officers are to distant from the men no trust is formed and their is no confidence in their leadership skills!

    Leave a comment:

  • Guest
    Guest

  • medic
    Guest replied
    Tasty one this!

    Respect for rank comes from (in my opinion) being able to do the job well.
    I presume we are only disscussing officers here, But in my experience the best officer I ever worked with was a real hands on type (in itself very unusual in the Irish DF)

    If officers are going to be directly involved with trg they require a very high level of subject knowledge, and practical experience of what they are talking about.

    As an example can you imagine a newly commed 2/lt giving a lecture to a group of soldiers just back from an operational tour. Sure the troops will sit through it (probably because they have to) but more likely than not they will be thinking "how can this idiot lecture to us when he/she is straight off the conveyor belt"

    Also if an officer is seen to be unable to carry out a task better than the people he commands then any credibility he has goes out the window. I'm not saying offr's are infallable, but if they are going to put themselves on show, they are as well to ensure they are very good at what they are doing.

    To quote a British Army LT Col "The secret of being a good officer is to do exactly what your NCO's tell you to do and then make it look like it was your idea in the first place"

    Leave a comment:

  • yellowjacket
    Potential Liability

  • yellowjacket
    replied
    This topic kinda got ignored on its first outing, any contributions?

    Leave a comment:

  • kermit
    Closed Account

  • kermit
    started a poll Methods of Command

    Methods of Command

    38
    Hands on Approach
    23.68%
    9
    Hands off
    2.63%
    1
    Combination
    73.68%
    28
    LordFlash meant to post:
    Since there was a posting on comissions and officers, perhaps we should have a poll on methods of command?
    Which is best:
    A) The hands on (light infantry) approach (involved with training, familiarity with the ranks, tasking the troops with self disipline)
    B) The hands off approach (leave training in the hands of NCO's, keep a distance from the rankers, strict imposed disipline)
    C) Combination of both
Working...
X